Opinion: Mauricio Pochettino's first USMNT roster may be disappointing, but it makes sense

The daunting task ahead of Mauricio Pochettino, at least in the early going, was evident in his first roster as coach of the U.S. men’s national team.

Of the 25 players Pochettino picked Wednesday for games against Panama and Mexico, 19 were also on the roster for the Copa America debacle. Only six of the 25 have made fewer than 10 appearances with the USMNT, and two of those are goalkeepers.

There might be other players out there who could be contributors to the USMNT in the 2026 World Cup, which the United States is co-hosting with Canada and Mexico. But having been introduced just three weeks ago, and with the World Cup less than two years away, time is at a premium for Pochettino.

So instead of hopscotching the globe in search of new wunderkinds, Pochettino watched as many games of current players as he could remotely. He sought advice and information through Zoom sessions and phone calls. He leaned heavily on the intel from the existing national team staff.

“That is why you are going to see a very similar roster from the last camp,” Pochettino said.

That might disappoint fans hoping Pochettino would send a message with a roster shakeup. But the USMNT's problem, Pochettino insists, is not a lack of talent.

This is arguably the golden generation for the USMNT, with many of its key contributors not only playing in Europe but having success. It’d be hard to find someone playing better in Serie A right now than Christian Pulisic, who has five goals and two assists in AC Milan’s first eight games. Weston McKennie went from being a goner at Juventus to a must-have in the lineup, scoring in Juve’s Champions League opener. Antonee Robinson is an anchor on the backline at Fulham, which has allowed five goals in six matches, tied for second-fewest in the Premier League.  

Ricardo Pepi got a rare start for the Dutch league’s PSV last weekend and responded with two goals. In England’s Championship, one step below the Premier League, Josh Sargent has three goals and three assists at Norwich City while Brenden Aaronsen has two goals and an assist at Leeds.

But the lack of success at the World Cup — the USMNT hasn’t gotten beyond the round of 16 in more than 20 years — coupled with a recent string of poor results means something isn’t working. Figuring that out is just as important, maybe even more so, than unearthing new talent.

“It’s so important … to set principles and to be ready when the players arrive this week,” Pochettino said.

“What we want to feel for them is the commitment, their personality, their character, their capacity to adapt to a new era, a new way to approach the games. That is going to be the key,” he added. “The capacity to adapt, thinking (first of) the collective and to give everything to try to be better.”

This doesn’t mean players called in for these first games — the USMNT plays Panama in Austin, Texas, Oct. 12 and then travels to Mexico to face El Tri on Oct. 15 — can be complacent. This is Pochettino’s starting point and his player pool, as well as how he uses it, could look vastly different by the summer of 2026.

Take the USMNT goalkeepers. Pochettino picked Matt Turner, the USMNT’s No. 1 ‘keeper since the World Cup in 2022, and longtime backup Ethan Horvath. He also called in Patrick Schulte, who has 10 clean sheets with the Columbus Crew and is considered one of the best young goalkeepers in Major League Soccer.

But in perhaps the biggest surprise of all on the roster, Pochettino recalled Zack Steffen, the USMNT’s former No. 1 goalkeeper who lost his starting job and then a spot on the 2022 World Cup squad amid injuries, lack of playing time and some very visible blunders.

Steffen has not played for the USMNT since a World Cup qualifier in March 2022. But he’s a starter in MLS, and Pochettino signaled that playing time will be a factor in his choice for goalkeeper.

“He deserves the opportunity to be with us,” Pochettino said of Steffen. “This will be a good opportunity to see him and analyze.”

The same goes for everyone on this roster. With the World Cup fast approaching, Pochettino doesn't have time to make change for change's sake. He's starting with what he's already got, and will go from there.

The USMNT roster

GOALKEEPERS: Ethan Horvath (Cardiff City), Patrick Schulte (Columbus Crew), Zack Steffen (Colorado Rapids), Matt Turner (Crystal Palace)

DEFENDERS: Marlon Fossey (Standard Liege), Kristoffer Lund (Palermo), Mark McKenzie (Toulouse), Tim Ream (Charlotte FC), Antonee Robinson (Fulham), Miles Robinson (FC Cincinnati), Joe Scally (Borussia Monchengladbach), Auston Trusty (Celtic) 

MIDFIELDERS: Brenden Aaronson (Leeds United), Gianluca Busio (Venezia), Johnny Cardoso (Real Betis), Weston McKennie (Juventus), Aidan Morris (Middlesbrough), Yunus Musah (AC Milan), Malik Tillman (PSV Eindhoven)

FORWARDS: Folarin Balogun (Monaco), Ricardo Pepi (PSV Eindhoven), Christian Pulisic (AC Milan), Josh Sargent (Norwich City), Timothy Weah (Juventus), Haji Wright (Coventry City)

Follow USA TODAY Sports columnist Nancy Armour on social media @nrarmour.